Women in Peace and Transition Processes

Fifteen years after the adoption of the landmark UN Security Council Resolution 1325, women remain significantly underrepresented in peace and political transition processes. A central challenge is the lack of evidence-based knowledge on the precise role and impact of women’s inclusion in peace processes.

Inclusive peace processes are gradually replacing the traditional exclusive peace deals negotiated solely between two or more armed groups. From Colombia to Libya and Myanmar, current peace processes seek to broaden participation at even the highest level of official peace negotiations. Although women often take part in these negotiations, there is still resistance to the greater inclusion of women. Our research work seeks to provide an evidence base to promote women’s participation and gender mainstreaming in all aspects of peacemaking and peacebuilding.

Research objective

Our research work on women in peace and political transition processes explores the roles and influence of women in a variety of peace, constitution-making, and political reform processes worldwide.

Methodology

The research analysed data from the “Broadening Participation in Political Negotiations and Implementation” research project conducted between 2011 and 2017 at the Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies in Geneva, Switzerland. This project explores how and under what conditions various actors in addition to the main negotiating parties have participated in and influenced peace processes and political transitions, by comparing more than 40 in-depth qualitative case studies of peace and constitution-making multi-stakeholder negotiations, and the implementation of negotiated agreements, ranging from 1989 to 2014.

Key Findings

  • Making women count is more important than counting women: what makes a difference for reaching and implementing sustainable peace agreements is the level of influence that women actually have on the process – not merely their numerical presence.
  • The chances of agreements being implemented are also much higher when women’s groups have stronger influence on the process.
  • Timing is key to achieving successful and effective inclusion of women in peace and transition negotiations. Early women’s involvement – preferably in the pre-negotiation phase – has often paved the way for sustained women’s inclusion throughout subsequent negotiations and agreement implementation processes.
  • Women’s inclusion takes place through different modalities, both at the negotiating table and beyond.

Outputs

The Report Making Women Count – Not Just Counting Women: Assessing Women’s Inclusion and Influence on Peace Negotiations, based on comparative evidence from 40 in-depth cases since 1989, is the largest qualitative comparative study of women’s participation in peace and transition processes to date. The report was originally prepared as an input to the Global Study in preparation for the High-level Review on the Implementation of UN Security Council Resolution 1325.

The Briefing Note Making Women Count in Peace Processes summarises the key findings from the comparative study on women’s inclusion and influence on peace negotiations.

Our series of women case studies in this series are based on findings of the “Broadening Participation” research project. The series explores the role of women – defined as relatively organised groups, including delegations of women, women’s civil society organisations, coalitions, or networks – in a range of peace, constitution-making, and political reform processes.

List of country case studies

Afghanistan / Burundi / Democratic Republic of the Congo / Fiji / Guatemala / Kenya / Liberia / Mexico / Nepal / Northern Ireland / Somalia / Somaliland / South Africa / Sudan / Tunisia / Yemen

Report,

Making Women Count - Not Just Counting Women: Assessing Women's Inclusion and Influence on Peace Negotiations

This report is based on the multi-year research project “Broadening Participation in Political Negotiations and Implementation”. It examines women’s inclusion and influence in peace processes.

April 2016|Steven Dixon, Anna-Lena Schluchter, Jacquie True, Thania Paffenholz, Nick Ross,

Briefing Note,

Making Women Count in Peace Processes

This briefing note summarises key findings on women's inclusion and influence in peacebuilding and peace processes. It is based on the “Broadening Participation in Political Negotiations and Implementation” research project.

February 2016|IPTI,

Case Study,

Women in Peace and Transition Processes: Burundi (1996–2014)

This case study analyses women’s influence in Burundi’s Arusha Peace and Reconciliation Agreement and Implementation process (1996-2014).

December 2018|Jane Linekar,

Case Study,

Women in Peace and Transition Processes: Democratic Republic of the Congo (2001–2003)

This case study analyses women’s influence in the Inter-Congolese Dialogue (2001-2003).

November 2017|Anne Zachariassen,

Case Study,

Women in Peace and Transition Processes: Fiji (2012)

The case study discusses women’s influence in Fiji’s Constitution-drafting process (2012).

December 2018|Estefanía Charvet, Hannah Brown,

Case Study,

Women in Peace and Transition Processes: Guatemala (1994–1999)

This case study analyses women’s influence in Guatemala’s Negotiations for a Firm and Lasting Peace (1994-1999).

May 2017|Anne Zachariassen,

Case Study,

Women in Peace and Transition Processes: Kenya (2008–2013)

The case study analyses women’s influence in Kenya’s National Dialogue and Reconciliation process (2008-2013).

August 2016|Estefanía Charvet,

Case Study,

Women in Peace and Transition Processes: Liberia (2003–2011)

This case study analyses women’s influence in Liberia’s Comprehensive Peace Agreement negotiation and implementation process (2003-2011).

April 2018|Franzisca Zanker,

Case Study,

Women in Peace and Transition Processes: Mexico (1994–2001)

This case study analyses women’s influence in Mexico’s Chiapas peace process (1994-2001).

April 2018|Nick Ross,

Case Study,

Women in Peace and Transition Processes: Nepal (2008–2012)

This case study analyses women’s influence women in Nepal’s First Constituent Assembly (2008-2012).

July 2017|Estefanía Charvet,

Case Study,

Women in Peace and Transition Processes: Northern Ireland (1996–1998)

This case study analyses women’s influence in Northern Ireland’s Belfast (Good Friday) Agreement (1996-1998).

December 2018|Alexander Bramble,

Case Study,

Women in Peace and Transition Processes: Somalia (2000)

This case study analyses women’s influence in Somalia’s National Peace Conference (2000).

September 2018|Anne Zachariassen,

Case Study,

Women in Peace and Transition Processes: Somalia (2002–2004)

This case study analyses women’s influence in Somalia’s National Reconciliation Conference (2002-2004).

April 2019|Jasper Linke,

Case Study,

Women in Peace and Transition Processes: Somaliland (1993)

This case study analyses women’s influence in Somaliland’s Grand Conference on National Reconciliation (1993).

July 2017|Anne Zachariassen,

Case Study,

Women in Peace and Transition Processes: South Africa (1990–1998)

This case study analyses women’s influence in South Africa’s Transition to Democracy (1990-1998).

November 2018|Michael Aeby,

Case Study,

Women in Peace and Transition Processes – Sudan: Darfur (2009–2017)

This case study analyses women’s influence in Sudan’s Doha peace negotiations and implementation process (2009-2017).

September 2018|Jasper Linke,

Case Study,

Women in Peace and Transition Processes: Tunisia (2013-2015)

This case study analyses women’s influence in Tunisia’s Constituent Assembly and National Dialogue (2013-2015).

December 2019|IPTI,

Case Study,

Women in Peace and Transition Processes: Yemen (2011–2015)

This case study analyses women’s influence in Yemen’s Gulf Cooperation Council Initiative (2011-2015).

April 2018|Nick Ross,

Infographic,

Infographic: Women’s role in Afghanistan’s Bonn process (2001)

This infographic analyses women’s influence in Afghanistan’s Bonn Agreement Process (2001).

December 2019|IPTI,

Infographic,

Infographic: Women's role in Burundi's Arusha Peace and Reconciliation Agreement and Implementation (1996-2014)

This infographic analyses women’s influence in Burundi’s Arusha Peace and Reconciliation Agreement process (1996-2014).

May 2019|IPTI,

Infographic,

Infographic: Women’s role in the Democratic Republic of Congo’s peace process (2001–2003)

This infographic analyses women’s influence in the Inter-Congolese Dialogue (2001-2003).

June 2018|IPTI,

Infographic,

Infographic: Women’s role in Fiji's constitution-drafting process (2012)

This infographic analyses women’s influence in Fiji’s Constitution-drafting process (2012).

December 2018|IPTI,

Infographic,

Infographic: Women’s role in Guatemala’s peace process (1994–1999)

This infographic analyses women’s influence in Guatemala’s Negotiations for a Firm and Lasting Peace (1994-1999).

June 2018|IPTI,

Infographic,

Infographic: Women's role in Tunisia's National Dialogue (2013-2015)

This infographic analyses women’s influence in Tunisia’s Constituent Assembly and National Dialogue (2013-2015).

December 2019|IPTI,

Infographic,

Infographic: Women’s role in Kenya’s peace process (2008–2013)

This infographic analyses women’s influence in Kenya’s National Dialogue and Reconciliation process (2008-2013).

June 2018|IPTI,

Infographic,

Infographic: Women’s role in Liberia’s peace process (2003-2011)

This infographic analyses women’s influence in Liberia’s Comprehensive Peace Agreement negotiation and implementation process (2003-2011).

October 2018|IPTI,

Infographic,

Infographic: Women’s role in Mexico’s peace process (1994-2001)

This infographic analyses women’s influence in in Mexico’s Chiapas peace process (1994-2001).

October 2018|IPTI,

Infographic,

Infographic: Women’s role in Nepal’s constitution-making process (2008–2012)

This infographic analyses women’s influence in Nepal’s First Constituent Assembly (2008-2012).

June 2018|IPTI,

Infographic,

Infographic: Women’s role in Northern Ireland’s Belfast (Good Friday) Agreement (1996-1998)

This infographic analyses women’s influence in Northern Ireland’s Belfast (Good Friday) Agreement (1996-1998).

December 2018|IPTI,

Infographic,

Infographic: Women’s role in Somalia's peace process (Arta, 2000)

This infographic analyses women’s influence in Somalia’s National Peace Conference (2000).

November 2018|IPTI,

Infographic,

Infographic: Women’s role in Somalia's National Reconciliation Conference (2002-2004)

This infographic analyses women’s influence in Somalia’s National Reconciliation Conference (2002-2004).

December 2019|IPTI,

Infographic,

Infographic: Women's role in Somaliland's peace and political reform process (1993)

This infographic analyses women’s influence in Somaliland’s Grand Conference on National Reconciliation (1993).

June 2018|IPTI,

Infographic,

Infographic: Women’s role in South Africa's Democratic Transition (1990–1998)

This infographic analyses women’s influence in South Africa’s Democratic Transition (1990–1998).

December 2018|IPTI,

Infographic,

Infographic: Women’s role in the Sudan (Darfur) peace process (2009-2017)

This infographic analyses women’s influence in Sudan’s Doha peace negotiations and implementation process (2009-2017).

November 2018|IPTI,

Infographic,

Infographic: Women’s role in Yemen’s peace and transition process (2011–2015)

This infographic analyses women’s influence in Yemen’s Gulf Cooperation Council Initiative (2011-2015).

November 2018|IPTI,

Infographic,

Factors Enabling and Constraining Women's Influence in Peace Processes

This infographic provides an overview of 19 factors enabling and constraining women’s influence in peacebuilding and peace processes.

December 2019|IPTI,

Report,

Reimagining Peacemaking: Women’s Roles in Peace Processes

This report discusses women’s influence in peace and transition processes. It offers insight into how a rethinking of the traditional approach to peacemaking can offer pathways to sustainable peace.

June 2015|Andrea Ó Súilleabháin, Marie O’Reilly, Thania Paffenholz,

Briefing Note,

Fresh Insights on the Quantity and Quality of Women’s Inclusion in Peace Processes

This briefing note summarises expert views on women's inclusion in peace processes. It is based on findings from the “Broadening Participation” and “Civil Society and Peacebuilding” Projects.

May 2013|Antonia Potter Prentice, Cate Buchanan, Thania Paffenholz,